Warning

Patients with widespread pain, fatigue and cognitive symptoms often have a non-mechanical cause that is missed if the presentation is treated as ordinary musculoskeletal pain.

The four key masqueraders to consider are:

  • Axial Spondyloarthropathy (AxSpA)
  • Spondyloarthropathy (SpA)
  • Connective Tissue Disease (CTD)
  • Lyme disease

Each has distinct screening features which guide investigation and onward referral.

Assessment

Initial presentation

  • Generalised muscle or joint pain
  • Debilitating fatigue
  • Reduced cognition / concentration / "brain fog"

Axial Spondyloarthropathy (AxSpA) — screening criteria

Low back pain that started before age 45 and lasting over 3 months, with any of:

  • Morning stiffness >1 hour
  • Pain waking patient in the second half of the night
  • Alternating or persistent buttock pain
  • Improves with movement, worsens with rest
  • Improves within 48 hours of NSAIDs
  • First-degree relative with spondyloarthritis
  • Current or past arthritis
  • Current or past enthesitis
  • Current or past psoriasis

Useful tools:

Spondyloarthropathy (SpA) — key clinical features

Inflammatory pain (worse in the morning lasting over 30 min, better on movement, worse with rest) with:

  • Asymmetrical joint involvement
  • Dactylitis — swelling of an entire finger or toe (sausage digit)
  • Enthesitis — most commonly Achilles tendonitis or plantar fasciitis
  • Recurrent or persistent peripheral arthritis

Extra-articular features:

  • Psoriasis
  • Inflammatory bowel disease
  • Uveitis
  • Family history of SpA

Connective Tissue Disease (CTD) — screening features

  • Malar / butterfly rash
  • Photosensitivity
  • Recurrent mouth ulcers
  • Diffuse alopecia
  • Raynaud's disease
  • Sicca symptoms (dry eyes, dry mouth)
  • Lymphadenopathy
  • No diurnal pattern to symptoms

Lyme disease — screening features

  • Flu-like illness prior to symptom onset
  • Tick exposure or risk of tick exposure (see below)
  • Rash prior to symptom onset — note that not all Lyme rashes have the bullseye appearance and not everyone develops a rash (CDC rash poster)
  • Widespread ache/pain without inflammatory signs
  • Non-dermatomal numbness or paraesthesia

Tick exposure risk assessment — ask about:

  • Known tick bite
  • Occupational exposure: farming, forestry, veterinary, gardening, military, outdoor work
  • Recreational exposure: mountain biking, walking or running off paths (e.g. fell running), gardening, time in grass / woods / forests
  • Travel to high-risk areas, e.g. Highlands & Islands of Scotland

Absence of a known tick bite does not exclude a tick bite — ticks are small, often bite in skin creases (hard to see), and bites are typically painless.

Primary care management

AxSpA

  • 4 or more screening criteria → refer to Rheumatology
  • 3 criteria → request HLA-B27 and other bloods as appropriate; refer to Rheumatology if positive

SpA

  • Assess for inflammatory features and extra-articular signs as above
  • Bloods as appropriate (FBC, ESR, CRP, U&E)
  • Note that normal bloods do not exclude SpA

Connective Tissue Disease

  • Request bloods including ANA, FBC, ESR, CRP, U&E and urine dip; add other bloods as clinically indicated

Lyme disease

  • Request Lyme serology (NHS-accredited lab) and other bloods as appropriate; consider BBV testing
  • Sensitivity can be limited, especially in the immunocompromised
  • Antibiotics may be started before serology results if clinical suspicion is strong (results can take several weeks) — see NICE CKS Lyme disease
  • Signpost to Lyme Resource Centre

Who to refer

Rheumatology — AxSpA

  • 4 or more screening criteria, or
  • 3 criteria with positive HLA-B27

Rheumatology — SpA

  • Dactylitis, persistent joint pain and swelling, or enthesitis with a history of psoriasis, inflammatory bowel disease or uveitis
  • HLA-B27 positive with symptoms
  • Clinical suspicion remains high despite normal blood tests

Rheumatology — CTD

  • Raised ANA / inflammatory markers, or
  • Clinical suspicion remains high despite normal blood tests

Lyme disease — onward referral

  • Ongoing symptoms despite 2 courses of antibiotics with positive serology → refer to Dr Sharon Irvine OPAT (outpatient antibiotic) service as per NICE guidance
  • Strong clinical suspicion but negative serology → discuss with Infectious Diseases / Microbiology regarding further testing
  • Ongoing symptoms with negative bloods and no strong clinical suspicion of Lyme → refer to the appropriate specialty for the dominant symptom (e.g. joint pains → Rheumatology; neuropathy → Neurology)

Summary

Condition

Key features

Action

AxSpA

Inflammatory back pain, age <45

Refer to Rheumatology if ≥4 criteria, or 3 criteria with HLA-B27 positive

SpA

Asymmetrical arthritis, enthesitis, dactylitis, psoriasis / IBD / uveitis

Refer to Rheumatology

CTD

Rash, ulcers, alopecia, Raynaud's, sicca symptoms

ANA + Rheumatology referral

Lyme disease

Tick exposure, widespread aches/pains, fatigue

Serology ± start antibiotics

Editorial Information

Last reviewed: 01/05/2026

Next review date: 01/05/2028

Version: 1.0

Reviewer name(s): Deena Dean.