Warning

Services available

There is a dedicated ED clinic based at Ayr Hospital. At this clinic patients can be shown how to do intracavernosal injections. The clinic does not prescribe testosterone, and referrals for low testosterone should be directed to Endocrinology.

Advice where required via clinical mail box: aa.clinicalurologyayrhospital@aapct.scot.nhs.uk.

UCS, urgent or routine outpatient referrals via SCI gateway.

Assessment

Erectile dysfunction pathway1.

1. NHSGGC. Erectile dysfunction.

Reproduced and adapted with kind permission of NHSGGC.

When & how to refer

Through SCI Gateway.

For professional to professional referrals and advice related to psychosexual health, please contact Sexual Health Services (contact details only available through intranet)

Practice points

Treatment - Erectile dysfunction

Patients should be informed that there is a range of treatments which will help to resolve their problem. Almost all patients can be treated, provided they are prepared to use second line (intracavernosal self injection, vacuum pump, MUSE) and third line (penile implant) treatment options. They should be encouraged to report back if first line treatment (tablets) fail. While we recommend that only first line treatment is carried out in Routine General Practice, there is further explanation of other treatment options listed for information and as a reference for discussion with patients.

5 – Phosphodiesterase Inhibitors

This is the first line treatment for most patients. There is no direct comparison between the three 5-PDE inhibitors in good quality comparative trials, but essentially they all work similarly well in terms of efficacy, safety and tolerability. The overall efficacy in the broad population is around 68%, with a lower response rate in difficult patients such as diabetics (48%-56%)

Contraindication to all 5-PDE inhibitors are short or long acting nitrates.

Consider cardiology review for patients presenting for ED treatment who receive nitrates to amend angina treatment. It may be worth considering whether patients really need their nitrates. For instance, some patients may have a GTN spray for angina, which they rarely use. These might be suitable for discontinuing their nitrates. Discuss options with patient - possibly start a shorter acting 5 PDE inhibitor under specific instructions that they absolutely must avoid taking/being given nitrates while have taken the 5 PDE inhibitor – this requires good patient compliance.

Others may be considered for change of long acting nitrates to other drug groups at their next cardiology review.

Dosage

There is a “learning curve” for these drugs.

  1. We recommend a course of 8 tablets for initial trial.
  2. Most patients with complete erectile failure should be commenced on the higher treatment doses to benefit from the reassurance gained by successful treatment initially (they can try to reduce the dosage later). Only patients with neurological disease and those with partial ED should be started on the lower doses.
  3. Patients need to be advised that these drugs only work with concomitant adequate sexual stimulation.
  4. Patients need to be informed about the optimum time for intercourse in relation to drug intake.

Safety and side effects of 5-phosphodiesterase inhibitors

Side effects

All 5 PDE inhibitors have similar transient side effects of:

  • Headache, flushing, indigestion and a stuffy nose.
  • The frequency of side effects is dose dependant and duration similar for all drugs.
  • Vomiting, dizziness, painful red eyes and raised intra-ocular pressure may also occur.
  • Hypersensitivity reactions and priapism (see below) are rare.
  • Sildenafil has a low incidence of visual side effects, typically blue colour changes and a bright vision (only rarely seen with vardenafil and not with tadalafil). There are no permanent visual effects, but sildenafil is contraindicated in retinitis pigmentosa.

Cardiac safety

There is no increased incidence of myocardial infarction with these drugs. All drugs are contraindicated in patients taking nitrates as they potentiate their effect. 5 PDE inhibitors also interfere with alpha-blockers. (This may be circumvented in patients taking alpha-blockers for bladder outflow obstruction by taking the alpha-blocker in the morning and the 5PDE inhibitor in the evening, eg. tamsulosin, alfuzosin, doxazosin.) Patients with significant cardiac disease should be assessed cardiologically before using 5PDE inhibitors (see below).

Sexual activity is mild exercise and should be within the physical capacity of most men. Peak heart rates and systolic pressures achieved during intercourse only reach 60-70% of the maximum values achieved in a treadmill test. The workload equates with walking at 3 miles per hour on the flat for older men or with walking at 4.2 mile per hour up a 16% gradient (or cycling at 10 miles per hour) for younger men. Priapism: this very rare, but potentially devastating complication of a prolonged painful erection of more than 4 hours is an emergency requiring immediate treatment. Patients should be warned about it, so they can seek help early. Latest after 24 hrs smooth muscle necrosis occurs, resulting in impotence.

ED treatments in secondary care

Intracavernosal prostaglandin injections

Several alprostadil preparations are available and injection is now aided by a self injection pen. Intracavernosal injections work in a high proportion of patients, but require the preparedness to accept the injections and the dexterity to apply them.

Advantages:

  • Proved efficacy achieving good erections.
    • (94% in users at home)
  • Rapidly effective.
  • Suitable for most patients, few contraindications.
  • Recovery of spontaneous erections in some patients.
  • High patient and partner satisfaction.

Disadvantages:

  • Invasive, requiring injection.
  • Penile pain on injection (usually mild) is common.
  • Needs initial tuition for use.
  • Needs adequate manual dexterity and eyesight.
  • Penile fibrosis in longterm use possible.
  • Prolonged erections in <5% and priapism in 1%
  • Contraindicated in bleeding disorders + anticoagulation.

Transurethral alprostadil (MUSE)

Alprostadil given transurethrally avoids the need for intracavernosal injection, but is overall less effective and has a higher incidence of penile pain leading to discontinuation of treatment. MUSE application is somewhat complex, requiring insertion after micturition, manual dexterity and good eyesight. Initial tuition is recommended (there is a patient video from the manufacturer). Longterm studies and follow-up have not been reported. It can be used in needlephobic and in anticoagulated patients.

Advantages:

  • Efficacy in providing erections in about 65%
  • Lower risk of priapism than intracavernosal injections.
  • Suitable for needle phobia.
  • Suitable for anticoagulated patients.

Disadvantages:

  • Long term efficacy and side effects uncertain.
  • Less effective than intracavernosal injections.
  • Mild penile pain in 10-29%, (11% MUSE discontinuation)
  • Possible urethral discomfort + vaginal discomfort.
  • Needs manual dexterity and good eyesight.
  • Slower onset of action than intracavernosal alprostadil.
  • Possible discomfort in lower limb varicosities.

Vacuum devices

A vacuum device consists of an external cylinder fitted over the penis to allow the air to be pumped out, resulting in engorgement of the penis with blood. A constriction ring is then fitted to the base of the penis to maintain this “erect” state. It is suitable for a wide range of patients with chronic or occasional ED, whatever the cause. Satisfaction rates with this are reported as varying widely, probably reflecting physicians enthusiasm and patient teaching to some extend. It probably works well in couples that jointly decide to use this method, although the method has some definite disadvantages.

Vacuum pumps can be bought directly by mail order and are a single investment cost compared to ongoing costs of medication. Those patients wishing to try this method straight away can be given the list of manufacturers. Most patients may wish to try the method first and should be directed to the Urology Department, where some dedicated pumps are available for patients to try.

Advantages:

  • Low incidence of side effects.
  • Suitable for long term use.
  • Suitable in failed oral therapy.
  • Suitable in patients on nitrates.
  • Single investment cost.

Disadvantages:

  • Contraindicated in bleeding disorders + anticoagulation.
    • (probably suitable in most patients with antiplatelet therapy [aspirin, clopidogrel, dipyridamole, NSAIDS], unless they easily get skin bruises)
  • Lack of spontaneity and cumbersome.
  • Can be uncomfortable, ejaculation may be impaired.
  • Pivoting at base of penis and “cold penis” for partner.
  • Overall less satisfaction than with injection therapy suggested1

Penile prosthesis

This is third line treatment reserved for those who have failed other treatments, have contraindications to other treatments or decline other treatments. This has a high patient and partner satisfaction rate and is a very effective treatment. Penile prosthesis insertion will however irreversibly damage penile cavernosal tissues and a return to other treatment forms is subsequently impossible. In reality most patients wishing to undergo surgery for ED have nonfunctioning cavernosal tissues already. Technical success rates are high and the risk of infections is low with modern antibiotic covered prosthesis and prophylaxis.

Advantages

  • High technical success rates.
  • High patient and partner satisfaction.
  • Low early revision and removal rates.
  • No tablet taking or injections.
  • May be suitable in anticoagulated patients.
  • Works in penile fibrosis.
  • Replacement prosthesis cost covered by lifetime guarantee.

Disadvantages:

  • Invasive, operative procedure.
  • Infection risk was 2-16%, lower with new prosthesis.
  • Infection requires salvage procedure or removal.
  • Rare complications of erosion, migration and penile necrosis2
  • Perineal pain can persist for 1-2 months.
  • Semi-rigid and malleable devices protrude.
  • Moderate risk of longterm mechanical failure.

Other penile surgery

Exceptionally patients may be considered for vein ligation surgery, vein or graft surgery or arterial revascularisation surgery for ED.

References

  1. Soderdahl, D.W., Thrasher, J.B. and Hansberry, K.L. (1997), Intracavernosal drug-induced erection therapy versus external vacuum devices in the treatment of erectile dysfunction. British Journal of Urology, 79: 952-957. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1464-410X.1997.00147.x
  2. Evans, (1998), The use of penile prostheses in the treatment of impotence. British Journal of Urology, 81: 591-598. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1464-410x.1998.00597.x

Editorial Information

Last reviewed: 14/11/2025

Next review date: 14/11/2027

Author(s): Urology consultants.

Version: 01.0

Approved By: Urology Directorate Governance Group